autohitch logo
is give me the vin legit Review: Is Give Me the Vin Legit

When it comes to selling a used car, we’re always looking for the fastest and most hassle free methods.

A service I heard about on the radio called promises such a hassle-free process to get cash for your vehicle without ever leaving home.

But is Give Me the vin legit? Or is it just your typical dealer using clever marketing?

I decided to look into it so you don’t have to, and what I find is actually going to surprise you.

What This Review Will Cover

Company OverviewIntroduction to Give Me The Vin
LegitimacyLegitimacy assessment
Pricing and OffersOffers and pricing details
Customer ServiceService quality evaluation
TrustworthinessTrust assessment in transactions
Service Speed and EaseService efficiency and user-friendliness
Old/High Mileage Car PurchasesBuying policy for old/high mileage cars
Car SalesInformation on car sales by the company
Final VerdictComprehensive conclusion of the review
What This Review Will Cover

*All sources cited below

What is Give Me the Vin? is an online platform that allows you to get a cash offer for used cars by simply providing some basic details like the make, model, year, mileage, and condition.

The company claims to make the selling process as easy as 1-2-3, and if you accept their offer, they arrange for free pickup of your car at your home and you get paid on the spot.


One of the biggest concerns people have had with online car buyers is whether they are actually a real, reputable business or just a scam with some incredible marketing.

What I Found

In the case of, there are several indicators I found that point to it being exactly what it claims to be:

  • The company was founded in 2013 by John Clay Wolfe, a long-time player in the auto industry. It has physical locations across the U.S. to facilitate vehicle pickups and payments.
  • has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, with relatively few complaints for a company of its size. BBB Profile.
  • There are numerous video testimonials from people who have successfully sold their cars through the service and received prompt payment as promised. Video Review.
  • The company has been featured and vetted by reputable media outlets like NBC’s Today Show.

While no business is perfect, the overall evidence suggests is a legitimate car buying platform, not some fly-by-night scam operation.

Pricing and Offers

Of course, legitimacy is just one part of the equation – you also want to make sure they’re going to give you at least a fair price for your car.

Reviews indicate’s offers are generally competitive with other major car buyers like Carvana and Carmax.

However, some seller reviews state they were able to get higher prices selling their car privately or at a dealership.


  • Givemethevin does have a policy to beat offers from competitors like CarMax. If you provide them with CarMax’s offer letter, they guarantee to beat that price or pay you $100
  • Offers from Givemethevin might start low, but they do allow you to counter offer and negotiate

My thoughts

It’s not shocking to me that higher prices can be had selling privately, but when people say they got more for a trade at a dealership, it’s very possible the dealer manipulated the deal to show a higher trade in value.

Expert Tip: When you are thinking of selling your car to a car buyer such as Givemethevin over trading in at a dealership, know that when you trade in at a dealership, the price of your car comes off of the taxable amount. So, if you buy a $30,000 car and your trade was $10,000, you would only pay the tax on $20,000 which is an additional savings of $700 dollars.

Related Articles to Read:

Customer Service

When it comes to customer service, seems to do a great job. While there are some complaints about low offers or disagreements over vehicle condition, most reviewers give high marks for the easy process and responsive representatives.

Review Snippet: “The rep was very professional and made the process easy. I’d definitely use them again,” said one Trustpilot reviewer. Read more Trustpilot reviews about Givemethevin.


Another part of Givemethevin that I wanted to review was their transaction process. A few things I was looking at were:

  • When they make offers, how often do they change them when picking up the car?
  • Are they open and honest that they need to make money so their prices are lower than private party sales?
  • Are there hidden fees?
  • Is the vehicle inspection process open and honest with detailed expectations?

Here is what I discovered:

  • All cash offers are firm, guaranteed prices with no negotiation needed. What you see is what you get BUT your cars condition must be verified which anyone buying a car would do.
  • The company in fact is upfront that its offers may be below private party pricing and that this is in exchange for the convenience factor.
  • There are no fees or obligations until you officially accept an offer. Getting a quote is free with no strings attached.
  • allows a 7-day inspection period after pickup in case there are any issues with the transaction.

While no system is perfect, Givemethevin’s policies seem designed to create a fair, transparent process that is worth trusting.

Speed and Ease of Use

One of’s biggest selling points is the speed and simplicity of its service compared to other car selling options. So, next I wanted to see if this was true.

Claim by the company

Getting an online quote takes just a few minutes, and the company claims it can pick up your vehicle and pay you in as little as 24-48 hours in many cases.

What I found

Numerous customer reviews do validate that the process is fast from start to finish. “Sold two cars to them and it was the easiest experience ever,” said one seller.

How they Do This

One of the reasons the process to be paid is quicker is that they use live cashable checks when they pickup your car rather than competitors that use non cashable bank drafts.

For people who prioritize convenience and a quick sale over maximizing profit, seems to deliver on its promise of hassle-free transactions.

Does Give me the VIN buy old/high mileage cars?

Yes, Givemethevin does buy older and high mileage vehiclesbut they wont buy anything considered “Junk” or under $1,000

Does Give me the vin sell cars?

No, Give me the vin does not sell cars directly to consumers, they resell them at auto auctions or other wholesalers.

My Final Verdict on

So should you use to sell your car?

Based on what I was able to find through some extensive research, the service appears to be a legitimate, trustworthy option that offers a fair price in exchange for an exceptionally easy selling experience.

While you usually will get a bit more money going the private sale route, provides a solution for people wanting to avoid the hassles of listing, showing, negotiating and transferring paperwork themselves.

As with any major transaction, my advice is to get multiple quotes so that you know you’re getting a competitive and fair offer.

Selling to a service like Give me the vin isn’t for everyone or every car, but for many sellers, that convenience is well worth the modest tradeoff in maximum pricing.

Methodology For My Review

Methodology For My Review
– I spent several days watching numerous YouTube videos from car experts and Givemethevin customers
– I reviewed user comments on forums like Reddit and Quora
– I read numerous reviews on trusted review sites like Trustpilot, BBB, and Yelp
How I reviewed

Sources For This Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Steve Momot - Author

Steve Momot - Author

Steve, a seasoned expert in the automotive industry, formerly held a car dealer license in Florida. With extensive experience spanning across car trading and mechanical work, he founded Autohitch. His mission? To guide both buyers and sellers through the intricate maze of car purchasing, ensuring a seamless and informed experience. Outside of the automotive world, Steve has a passion for fishing and capturing the beauty of nature through photography.


Share on.

Table of Contents